Comments on Are bloggers bad judges?

Go to vogueAdd a commentGo to Are bloggers bad judges?

You know I have to agree with Nautikos, simply, "It's a bloomin' mystery to me" as well.  I just write and enjoy writing and if someone else enjoys what I write and share, wow, I'm mystified frankly.  and above all, honored.  I do know, from years of being in this field that rejection is so commonplace and you gain a thicker skin as time goes on.  ~ Write on Vogue...~Elyse

posted by elysianfields on July 2, 2008 at 9:13 PM | link to this | reply

I often
find that I don't really understand some peoples' standards.  But the people that it matters to me the most are the people who may or may not publish me.  For blogit, I am true to myself and just enjoy posting and reading others, so that I don't worry so much about my popularity here.  I get alot out of Blogit and that is what matters.  I have been published before but rejection is still just around the bend.  There has been a shift in the amount of encouraging rejections so that many of them say they enjoyed it 'but it is not for us', so that I feel like I may be on the brink of something.  What I feel overwhelmed with is trying to meet, say a literary journals, needs. I find it much easier to research to a certain extent then send out, because it is too dificult to determine each magazines exact tastes in something as broad as Literary fiction.  Sometime I hope to hit the nail on the head!  I don't expect overnight success but thinking realistically some time, if I keep trying, the timing being right, I can be what they are looking for.   

posted by KaBooM62 on July 2, 2008 at 12:21 AM | link to this | reply

I don't think there is any consistent factor involved or any great mystery
here my dear; if I take myself as an example it always depends on the imagery and how I relate to the piece in general and of course on my state of mind at the time of reading!  It has been the case for me also that something I write in haste and don't feel very happy about may incite more interest than something I painstakingly put together over a period of time!  It's all a matter of taste; take care

posted by mariaki on July 1, 2008 at 6:22 AM | link to this | reply

It's a bloomin' mystery to me, vogue!

But then, I'm not really a 'creative' writer anyway. My forte, if I have one, is as an analytical writer, an 'essayist', if you will, derived from my academic background. I will never be a writer of fiction, let alone a novelist - haven't got the imagination, lol.  

But I am convinced, though I can't 'prove' it, that different areas of writing, different forms of discourse, have different 'standards', more or less 'integral' to those areas. In some they are fairly rigid, in others they're 'open-ended'...

I don't know if any of this makes sense to you...

posted by Nautikos on July 1, 2008 at 5:45 AM | link to this | reply

I can relate my dear...there are so many entries here actually I would always come across with which are great and very promising yet, there's either 1 or none comment at all. While there are those which aren't really good for me but been commented on many times. I guess it depends really dear on who is reading. My own work goes the same way....

posted by __Purple_Mermaid11__ on July 1, 2008 at 2:20 AM | link to this | reply

That's a tough one to answer
I think that some times we see things in a story that others don't. Maybe it's the memory of something that happened and touched us but that outsiders can't feel. Maybe others see things in a piece that we don't. I'm still searching too. I some times send stuff about a place I really liked and get no answer from potentiel mags. and sometimes I get a yes for a small "insignificant" piece. WHo knows? Luck I suppose. But I enjoy your entries. Tschüs.

posted by auslander on July 1, 2008 at 2:12 AM | link to this | reply